Tag Cloud
Amid a sleugh of advertiser withdrawals and facing heat from the GLBT community, Rob Williams, one-third of KRXQ's "Rob, Arnie & Dawn" morning show, posted a statement on the show's website that can be summed up in four words: "We have failed you."
"We presented our opinions on a very sensitive subject in a hateful, childish and crude fashion," Williams wrote on his website, RobArnieAndDawn.com in a letter to listeners, "and then, given the chance to retract those remarks, we defended them."
The response comes nearly two weeks following an on-air segment in which Williams and co-host Arnie States called members of the transgendered community "freaks," "fruits" and describing them as having a "mental disorder" in which transgenders "bring attention to themselves."
"God forbid if my son put on a pair of high heels, I would probably hit him with one of my shoes," States quipped during the May 28th segment.
Since then, nine advertisers -- Chipotle, Snapple, Sonic, Bank of America, Verizon Wireless, Carl's Jr., Nissan North America, AT&T and McDonald's -- announced through the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) that they were withdrawing support from KRXQ. A tenth advertiser, Wells Fargo Bank, issued a statement saying they were not advertisers of KRXQ's breakfast program and had no intention of advertising with the station in the future.
On June 3rd, Williams and States, along with co-host Dawn Rossi, addressed the May 28th segment following an outcry of opposition from listeners throughout the United States and as far away as the United Kingdom. Williams and States appeared to defend their right to an opinion on the show and clarified that they, in no way, advocated violence toward children.
"They never meant to advocate any form of abuse," station manager Jim Fox told The Sacramento Bee's 21Q blog.
Williams went on to say in his statement posted on June 7th that no new "Rob, Arnie & Dawn" shows will air on KRXQ until Thursday, June 11th, at which time the breakfast show presenters will "say what needs to be said."
"Apologizing in a written, posted statement is a form of cowardice," Williams wrote.
The Rob, Arnie and Dawn Show, which is owned and produced by Williams, airs weekday mornings on KRXQ 98.5 FM in Sacramento, known on-air as "98Rock," and in syndication on KDOT 104.5 FM in Reno. The 12-year radio program has been no stranger to controversy in the past; in 2004, the show was fined $55,000 by the Federal Communications Counsel for "on-air indecency" following a complaint filed by James Peak.
And, clearly, changing the channel is not the only option; as a listener, you can let the sponsors know that you won't be buying their products if they sponsor a show in which a host is expressing his opinion that you don't like. (This is also free speech.) Yes, RAD have a right to their opinions, but it cuts both ways: those who oppose them have a right to their opinions, and the station can make the choice that they feel is appropriate. If you or RAD don't like it, you are free to start your own radio station.
mobilizes them to take action to oppose censorship, and assist in those efforts,
facilitates communications between local activists and national organizations,
devises new educational, advocacy, and media strategies to create a more hospitable environment for free speech and artistic freedom.
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." — Benjamin Franklin
Freedom of speech does not extend to radio presenters who are granted the ability to voice their opinion by corporate sponsors. It also does not protect journalists from just saying whatever they feel like saying -- hence why we have libel and slander laws.
So when someone says "They're exercising their freedom of speech!" this is only partially true. They're exercising their right to say what they feel like saying without fear of being repressed by their government (...except the FCC). Anyone else is fair game -- as we've seen from the way sponsors reacted when they pulled their advertisement.
however the people commenting, whether for or against, ARE exercising their freedom of speech, as are the sponsors/advertisers who have pulled their support - it is hypocritical to claim that you are supportive of free speech and then criticize the criticism which is generally a better example of free speech than the original show content
PICK ON SOMEBODY YOUR OWN SIZE
no child deserved the hate spewed from this show, and Rob and Arnie should be fired, and the station makes an earnest apology..
I agree if you don't like them turn the dial, but their popularity is a sad commentary on our society as a whole.
all of the sponsors emails can be found here
http://www.radisupportrobarnieanddawn.host56.com/
ironically any clicking on Google the advertisers of this web page take money from the people that dropped support of RAD and gives it to webmaster so click away.
btw unofficially Guitar Center has joined the Boycott....according to a GLAAD update.
if these clods had gone after ANY KID, my reaction would have been identical.
So you want to vent your toxic waste at someone, MAN UP and say it to an ADULT.
I don't know, just you know, it seems like it's the well if I can't have it noone can attitude with these situations.
Well I might have more to comment on later. I am still reading different articles, and forums regarding this situation. Plus I'm sure that someone will want to attack me for something I said.
Jason
I am not anti gay at all...how do you know I'm not gay? HMMM? I could care less what they do. The problem is, they care far too much about people having the freedom to say or speak as they see fit...talk about intolerance!
http://glaadblog.org/2009/06/08/update-glaad-speaks-with-krxq-management/
Autumn Sandeen a transgender journalist from Pam's House Blend may be on Thursday's show...she deserves it, Michael Rowe from Huffington Post has done a great job on this story.
The station made NO APOLOGY and made NO mention if Rob, Arnie,and dawn show is staying or going.
THIS was insulting in my opinion, and I will be DOUBLING my efforts writing the remaining sponsors of the HATE SHOW to boycott
GLAAD confirmed the eleventh sponsor Guitar Center has dropped their ads from KRXQ...bravo!
That's what liberals do when they don't like your free speech...they shut you up
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWHgUE9AD4s
I took down posts where you used inappropriate language.
jim: your speech isn't "free" when it's on somebody else's privately owned and operated website, any more than it would be on somebody else's privately owned and operated radio station
similarly, if you start saying something in somebody else's living room that they don't like and they ask you to leave their house, they haven't censored you or limited your "free speech" - they have more accurately exercised their own freedom of speech and association by not choosing to support/facilitate the things you happen to be saying
if you want free speech, stand on a street corner or start your own website or radio station
If you have questions about our policies or enforcement please direct questions to support@sacramentopress.com .
Seriously demeaning women saying you'll rape them in the rear, while flushing the toilet your force their head into. speaking of tiny girl's Halloween costumes as pink tacos, advertising Arnie's Christmas gifts with t-shirts unprintable, but one showed a dog mounting a woman.
So this heinous bit about abusing a kid is just the LAST STRAW.
btw...did no one notice Rob's webpages on etiquette, recipes, and how to dress, seems he's three sequins MY side of metrosexual...IMO
No one wins in this situation...
There is ZERO defense for spewing your abuse at a little kid....ANYONE'S KID.
This should be a BASIC baseline of community standards, it is INEXCUSABLE, and should be a third rail which kills an on line personalities career, and has a backlash on the advertisers second to NONE.
Attacking children doesn't make you cool, or edgy...it makes you DISGUSTING, and COWARDLY.
ELEVEN of those MAJOR corporations expressed their views...they WALKED.
I'll buy RAD a megaphone and a soap box and they can spew 24/7 on any corner in America.
Honey, this was SO popular when said with a white hood on.....in the 1940's
I've seen the racist Tyrone character Rob performs...David Duke must get tickled pinker.
The boys who hide under sheets used to use a string of slurs, as ONE WORD
"Commie-Jew-N*gger-F*ggot"...and these chuckle heads seem to be playing to the SAME audience.
Whether it was Black children they used firehouses and police dogs to attack, or blowing up churches killing little girls, or Japanese second and third generations thrown in Concentraion CAMPS, or "Protectors of children" from online predators caught harrassing Congressional pages, or alter boys or Boy Scouts raped by those the family TRUSTED, or the venom hurled at Ryan White when he was banned from schools, and his parents got death threats, or villages of children burnt with Napalm, or White Phosphorous, or ground water or lead paint toys poisoning kids.
WE DRAW A LINE...you DONT CROSS, and America changes.
Tactics like this(advertising attacks) only serve to harden the hearts of people that might have otherwise come to your side one day. I truly feel that GLAAD has damaged their own cause in the eyes of many “straight” people that would have supported them. To a point Prop 8 had the same effect, many people branded Prop 8 as against or outside of the “will of the people” wrongly. However this mind set was not countered and I feel (anecdotally) that a good portion of our state voted for prop 8 because of this reason. It gave people an excuse, “I don’t hate gay people, I just don’t think they are doing it the right way”. Sound like a similar argument?
Lastly I would like to say that while this is a heated subject many people on various different forums have been very aggressive in their support or condemnation of the show. You do understand that it’s not helping either cause? It’s just more of the same turn off that the tactic of bullying advertisers is.
Is it that hard to argue a subject passionately without resorting to rhetoric and mud slinging?
Advertisers are perfectly capable of making a decision based on what is best for their company's brand, and where they make the most sales, no one bullies them.
Attacking little kids was what caused rob, and Arnie's downfall. They need to OWN IT, so does the station who airs their garbage.
I believe in the right to speak your opinion. I wish there was not the option to change genders.
This gay/ transgender thing is out of control, I say be what you were born to be, love who your heart loves, and keep your love life personal. Allow a joint union between same sex but keep marriage between a man and a woman.
Shame to me that the RAD group must apologize, I imagine the majority of human life feels the same and are appalled by the things people do to be different.
The advertisers that pulled off the show should be boycotted for crumbling to the extremists.
Companies are very capable of placing their Ad dollars in the right place I agree, however taking your Ad dollars from the #1 rated radio show (by a wide margin) is not smart business. It can also not be truthfully said that these companies would have pulled their Ad money had it not been for pressure from GLAAD. Do you really think that these companies employ people to scan the stations they advertise on to make sure that there is nothing offensive going on?
My point isn’t whether or not either Rob or Arnie would have come around or not, or whether anyone else would for that matter. My point is that by going with the attack first approach you are automatically making that choice for them which is just as wrong as what they said.
All of this still seems to me to be for naught as the show looks on track to survive this and the sponsors will come running back when this wind has blown enough on this subject…I have yet to be told what any of you intend to do when that happens.
Fubar…
Boycotting the advertisers that left is also not the answer. These companies are also doing what they must to survive, no business wants bad press to this degree and though sad it is still a fact of life that this tactic can and will work. If you were to be successful in such a boycott the only thing you would accomplish is more un-employed people and a harder economy to live in.
The only real answer is to educate all parties to be more adult and rational in their thought process and to be able to have a reasonable dialogue with people that do not agree with you.
Two wrongs do not make a right, I am not absolving the Rob, Arnie and Dawn show of what they said, but I will not give a pass to the people that react just as badly without thinking and trying to solve the problem in a constructive way.
Lets be clear
RAD went on the attack FIRST, and attacked CHILDREN.
LGBTs and our allies COUNTER ATTACKED in reaction.
btw. when you attack kids, you have no moral high ground to defend, and LGBTs can be as harsh as we want in retaliation.
Clinton loved when some oaf took the first shot at him, because then he would be justified tearing into them, and no one thought him mean or out of line.
I was a supporter of the G-L-T movements until this. They've gone way too far in taking something so minor and making it serious. Instead, they had to abuse their power and fight the wrong battle. Why couldn't the people against this just suck it up and deal with the comment? Yet again, this country they live in is built on the right of free speech. Without it, we'd be nothing. And guess what? It's being taken away. It's not long before books that offend people are burned (read Fahrenheit 451...it has my arguement down perfectly) and people who have different opinions are imprisoned and killed. You don't think so? Really, this is just the start.
And to add, their employers know full well what RAD is like. They stated that to press, saying that this is normal RAD stuff. Those who oppose have their opinions, just like RAD does....but having an opinion does not mean you must make a dramatic protest and get someone to humiliate themselves. Being responsible for their "actions" means being responsible for an "ACTION" someone does. A statement means absolutely nothing unless it is a threat....which i heared nothing of.
I’m not sure if you’re so angry that you are not seeing what I am saying, purposefully trying to keep this argument on the wrong topic/trolling, or if I just am not articulating my responses to you clear enough.
I will only give this one more shot. You’re style, and that of GLAADs, of combating this issue is not going to make matters better for you in the long run. You will only get an apology like the one you are getting from the show Thursday morning, a meaningless one . And on top of that you will push people that may have been middle of the road on issues you care about further away from you. It is a lose/lose proposition for everyone involved.
For the record I never saw anything in the broadcast that pointed toward Arnie encouraging anyone to beat their children we will simply have to disagree on this point as well.
Keep your pyrrhic victory if you must, there are far too many of them going around for my liking. I look forward to your response if any…
http://www.mcclatchydc.com/nation/story/69843.html
So i wouldn't be confident this issue is going away for RAD, and i will boycott any advertiser of the show, until Rob and Arnie are FIRED.
Saying you'll hit a kid with your shoe and call him idiot and freak = CHILD ABUSE
Are you hard of hearing or is your wittle brainstem unable to process higher cognition.