STORYLINE Car-less in Sacramento

This storyline has only one article

Viewing thru of

Close timeline

Dear Car: I'm breaking up with you. Going carless in Sacramento

by Jana Saastad, published on July 13, 2012 at 12:16 PM

Community Tags culture transportation

No high resolution image exists...

Progress bar

Loading images
Slideshow image

The great American love affair with cars dates back nearly a century – about the time Henry Ford promised a car in every garage.

However, for me — a licensed driver of 34 years — my affair with cars has reflected more of the love-hate kind.

On the one hand, who doesn't love to sit behind the wheel of a sleek and powerful sports car, propelling down the highway at ungodly (and illegal) speeds? And what about the freedom found from driving an indefatigable, fat-tired Jeep over hill and dell? Or the requisite California experience of cruising back-country roads (or the Pacific Coast Highway) in an oversized classic convertible with the stereo blasting?


I have loved all of these things.

Here's where the hate part comes in: the expense.

The fact is we pay dearly for the pleasure of driving. Some households fork over nearly a third of their net incomes to drive and maintain “two cars in every garage” — to steal a line from the Simpsons. Sure, I understand driving in most parts of the United States is as much out of necessity as love, but the expense of owning and maintaining cars is outrageous and offensive.

The most obvious expense is the gut-wrenching experience of fillin' 'er up at the local gas station. It's a sad day when a crisp $100 bill doesn't cover the cost of a full tank of fuel. (Side note: From my visits to Europe and other international destinations, I am well aware that fuel is cheaper here in America than it is around the world, but that doesn't make $4 a gallon any easier to accept.)

And then the darn things break down.

It's a scientific fact that all moving parts will crap out, tires will wear thin or go flat, windshields crack, radio antennas get busted or stolen, not to mention all the other generally unexpected vehicular mishaps.

To make matters worse, I am not handy with mechanical things. In fact, that's an understatement. No, what I am is downright dyslexic, if not dimwitted, when it comes to disassembling bolts, cables, wires, wing nuts (I have been known to go wing nut over the simplistic car projects — like changing windshield wipers). So when things go sour with my automobiles, it's off to the mechanic for me to talk about something I know nothing about and pray I'm not forced to pawn a family heirloom to cover the expense of fixing the weird noise coming from the whatchamacallit on my car.

I'm sure my car-repair anxiety syndrome is a condition experienced by most car owners. Even my mechanically inclined friends say cars today are difficult to work on.

"Damn these computerized engines!"

I read recently that car mechanics are going back to school to keep up with the sophistication of today’s automobile. Where does that leave the layperson, or in my case, the mechanically incompetent?

Add to the cost of machine breakdowns: overpriced car washes, paint touch-up kits, routine oil changes, ever-rising vehicle insurance, the annual registration fees, which usually includes smog tests; and the inevitable parking and toll fees (because why not drive your car into the city where parking cost more than the two-martini lunch you're sharing with a friend at a four-star restaurant?).

I am done with the high-priced affair that is car ownership. As a returning resident of a highly dense Sacramento just-on-the-edge-of-an-urban neighborhood, I think I can go it alone. Therefore, as of today, I've dumped the gas-guzzling Ford F-150 and the shiny red Lexus G300 for my new status: carless in Sacramento.

To all the cars, Jeeps and trucks of my past: Thanks for the memories. You may have been expensive and unpredictable, but you never were a bore.

My regrets are few and I've enjoyed the pleasure of quick rides to here, there and everywhere. But I am done. And trust me, car: It's not me, it's definitely you.
 

Read 'How to get around when you're carless in Sacramento'

Liked this article? Share it with your friends:

Conversation Express your views, debate, and be heard with those in your area closest to the issue.RSS Feed

edited on  July 13, 2012 | 12:58 PM
If more people decide to abandon the car-centered lifestyle, the massive loss of tax revenue would send the state of California into instant bankruptcy.
5 4
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 12:43 PM
No it wouldn't. Driving a car is actually a loss in revenue whereas biking is a gain. The dollars spent end up going into local pockets instead of into foreign bank accounts. Pretty awesome. Abandon those cars with abandon!
1 1
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 12:58 PM
I’m glad you choose to get off the road; most people enjoy the freedom a car has to offer but for some (like you) it’s to complicated. Good luck with public transit in Sacramento… Hahaha!!!
3 2
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 1:23 PM
Richard Hanson. You're correct. Just like if every person ate healthy and quit smoking, doctors and other health care professionals would nearly go out of business. Or if people quit using drugs and drinking excessively, we'd cut loose at least half of our correctional officers and cops.
8 3
REPLY
July 15, 2012 | 12:38 AM
and what a wonderful world it would be. Yesterday I took Amtrak to Jack London Square where I then took a ferry to SF where I bombed the hills and ate great food all day long for my 54th birthday. No car involved total bliss. Show me a road trip via car that strokes the senses like that and Ill eat some crow.
4 1
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 1:25 PM
Please also see the sidebar which I forgot to link to the main story:

"How to get around when you are car-less in Sacramento"

http://www.sacramentopress.com/headline/70869/How_to_get_around_when_youre_carless_in_Sacramento
2 0
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 1:40 PM
We've added the link in the story, Jana! Thanks again for posting such great research and tips.
2 0
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 2:36 PM
I met someone back in Seattle who did not have a car, she lived in the downtown area. She explained to me that the downtown buses were free to ride and that most fares were very cheap. Before I caught myself, I asked "then who pays for that"? Her reply was "you do".
2 1
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 10:50 PM
While I wasn't involved in your conversation with your Seattle friend, it seems the right answer would have been "taxpayers," unless the free bus was paid by tourist through TOT funds. At any rate, it's pretty common knowledge that public transportation is heavily subsidized by taxpayers, including most of the smaller city airports (think Fresno, Stockton, Bakersfield). So car-less or not, we are all paying for transportation one way or another.
3 0
REPLY
July 14, 2012 | 6:26 PM
Txaxpayer, thats me. Yes, I asked her before pondering it, as I didn't connect the dots quickly. Just more income redistribution where car owners pay both ends.
1 2
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 10:48 AM
you also pay for accident clean up, investigations, ambulance and hospitalizations. bus fare typically helps poor people, students, elderly and other underrepresented people. So maybe that is why people would rather pay for all the road maintenance and other high-price items to keep wealthy car owners from riding a bus with... other people.
1 1
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 4:02 PM
I really appreciate this article. I dumped my car when I moved from the LA area to downtown Sacramento back in 2000, and have lived here without one ever since. We have a ways to go to create a more efficient and practical transit system that encourages more folks to sever their dysfunctional relationship with their car. I have to admit that i have had access to a vehicle over the years, thanks to good friends, significant others, and now Zipcar (that is absolutely fantastic) but i don't look forward to the day when either work or life reunites me with automobile ownership.
3 1
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 10:44 PM
Good for you! I bet you are in good shape and have saved lots of money :)
1 0
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 5:10 PM
If you can't maintain a car, please don't have any pets. Really. Or children.
0 8
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 10:40 PM
I did maintain my cars. What I wrote is that I am mechanically challenged. Big difference. And i have rescued countless animals throughout the years. One of them just died after 16 years of happy living under my roof. Think I'm doing OK in the pet raising department. Thanks for your comments.
5 0
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 5:35 PM
You're off to a great start with this! I'm trying to wean myself off the habit too--as soon as my current car dies (a 20 year old station wagon with enough mileage to reach the Moon, not a Lexus or F150) I'm trading it for a Zipcar membership. Don't be dissuaded by the mockery of those who assume that anyone who doesn't pledge allegiance to the United States of Automobilia is insisting on the unilateral destruction of all automobiles.

We're living in revolutionary times--a combination of high tech (online ordering of groceries and goods, smartphones that can tell you when the next bus is due or reserve you a Zipcar) and old-fashioned technologies (bikes, walking, transit, and a return to building mixed-use, walkable cities) are all becoming more popular, and more people are catching on.
8 2
REPLY
July 13, 2012 | 10:42 PM
Thanks for your positive comments and insight, William. I don't take the disgruntled too seriously. From what I have read, they did not read the article closely. Best wishes with ditching your car. I will let you know how life with Zipcar, on foot and on bike goes.
3 0
REPLY
edited on  July 14, 2012 | 8:27 AM
"I read recently that car mechanics are going back to school to keep up with the sophistication of today’s automobile. Where does that leave the layperson, or in my case, the mechanically incompetent?"

Good mechanics are usually going back to school, just like doctors tend to attend seminars and conferences regularly. However, the increasing use of computerized parts (on board diagnostics, etc.) is part of why I chose to buy my Jeep several years ago when my old car got wrecked. They may use a bit more gas, but I found a 4 cylinder manual and put some good street tires on it - the mileage isn't as bad as some people think. I think there's a tradeoff to owning any vehicle (it costs more to smog test mine because it's a bit older, but it's also cheaper to register and insure). They are VERY easy to work on and I understand cars even more now than when I was living with my ex the BMW/Mercedes mechanic. With help from my more car-knowledgeable friends, I've worked on my front brakes and water pump pulley, helped put in a new radiator and changed the serpentine belt (and now I also understand the difference between a serpentine belt vs. a timing belt or a timing chain) and oil ...it's really not that hard, stop telling yourselves this stuff, ladies! In general, I think that the complexity of many cars is vastly overstated, particularly to women, and it feeds into women's general anxiety about approaching anything that's mechanical and "scary". Sewing machines are more confusing to me, personally!;)
2 0
REPLY
July 14, 2012 | 10:39 AM
Very good article, Jana. When I moved from LA to SF some years ago and gave up my car, I actually had nightmares of being stranded. Then I found there is a great more freedom that comes with not owning a car not to mention health benefits.

Did you happen to check with Triple A or other sources to find out the annual cost (not cost per mile cost which is over 50 cents--depending on model, etc.) of owning, maintaining and operating a car? A few years ago it was about $8,000 a year average but I've been unable to find that data since (not good at it so that may be part the problem.) But when a person realizes it is good chunk of change for the privilege of driving, it is an eye opener that we can now afford other things in life that we may have been denying ourselves. .
3 0
REPLY
July 15, 2012 | 2:40 PM
I was car less all last year. Maybe if I lived downtown. Maybe if I did not have a teenager or want a life all over the city. Having no car just did not work for me. I missed the freedom to grocery shop in the wee hours of the morning. That and can you say the drive in's?
2 1
REPLY
JAT
Author thumbnail
July 17, 2012 | 9:42 AM
I applaud and envy you. The planet pays a colossal price for our love affair with cars, but for many of us it's not something we can realistically live without. Unless you live in the heart of a city, your choice is a very theoretical one. Good luck!
2 0
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 9:44 AM
i moved downtown in 1990 & got rid of my wheels in 1995. i have always worked in downtown as well so never made sense to have a car that i wasn't using. i walk, ride my bike, i am a ZipCar member & i love Hertz rental cars for wkend & weekly getaways. it's not for everyone & i will be the 1st to admit that our RT system is less than stellar. if anyone going to sign up for ZipCar let me know. i think i get credits for referrals!! thanks!
2 0
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 9:55 AM
Great article, and I feel you made a great choice. I live 10 miles from my work and have been car-free for a bit over 2 years now. I use a BionX powered cargo bike and an old Worksman tricycle for hauling stuff and a 3 speed classic style roadster for the neighborhood. In a few days the odo on my longtail bike will go over 10,000 miles. I could rent a car if I really needed to and get a new model that the agency will have to keep running, not me. However, cars actually outnumber drivers so there are plenty available anyway. My sentiment about cars has evolved from indifference to intolerance. Cars are noisy, dangerous and pollute more than anything. They give otherwise nice people Road Rage and empower the military industrial complex by extracting a major portion of peoples income. We have a health care crisis due to car crash injuries and epidemic obesity with 2 lane drive throughs at fast food outlets. This social addiction is clearly the single most harmful thing going on today. Like most things, used in moderation cars would be OK, but we have gone far beyond moderate use. Think you are not addicted to your car? Try going without it for 30 days! You will experience withdrawal, physical, mental and emotional. Like other addictions, there is a way out that will leave you healthier, happier and richer. The first step is admitting there is a problem.
1 0
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 10:12 AM
I have been carless in midtown for 5 years and have loved every minute of it.
1 0
REPLY
July 17, 2012 | 4:26 PM
Going carless in Sacramento has its limitations given the operational limitations of SacRT. Service hours and frequency of service is a major factor in accomplishing the mission of providing quality customer service to existing clientele and increasing ridership.
1 0
REPLY
July 18, 2012 | 9:07 AM
Wise choice, though sometime in about December you may question it some.

For getting about town you might try an eBike...about as fast as a car at a fraction of the cost, plus many other benefits. For inclement weather if you do not need speed, try an NEV - neighborhood electric vehicle. Remember too that the EV requires a lot less maint. than a gas burner.

http://www.evsroll.com/Electric_Car_Prices.html

If you need a car, try the new Mitsubishi iMiev...it is a real deal after rebates.

Of course there is light rail and the bus in other situations.

EVsRock!
0 0
REPLY
July 25, 2012 | 12:46 PM
I am looking into eBikes. As for December, I know I have thought about that. Luckily, I work from home so I'm subjected to the elements on a daily basis. We'll see how it goes. Thanks for your comments.
0 0
REPLY
July 25, 2012 | 12:47 PM
"not" subjected to the elements... : )
0 0
REPLY
Leave a Comment
User icon
Type your comment in the box below Edit your comment in the box below

Type tags into the box below. Use commas to separate your tags.

Please Log in or Sign up

Existing Members

Sign In Progress bar Forgot Password?

New Users Create an Account Here
Progress bar
Verification email has been sent. To validate your account open the link provided in the message.
There was a problem sending your verification email. Please contact support@sacramentopress.com
Progress bar Login background Tag cloud top Tag cloud background Tag cloud bottom Login manager background